ESG ETFs X-Ray – Comparison of largest ETFs

THE DEFINITIVE GUIDE TO SUSTAINABLE INVESTING - PART 5

This article is part of Bankeronwheels.com definitive guide to Sustainable Investing.

We previously covered the shocking truth behind most ESG Ratings. 

Yet, despite the irrelevance of ESG Ratings there are still ways to invest sustainably.

Selecting the right ESG & SRI benchmark is a great starting point. 

Now, let’s look at what investments you will be exposed to because that’s going to be a significant driver of ETFs’ performance. 

Spoiler – I hope you like the taste of Coke. And Pepsi, too. 

ADVERTISEMENT
Book a coaching session with us

Beginners often ask us:

  • How do I reach my goals  What investments do I need to take into consideration when e.g. Taking a Sabbaticalbuying a House or saving for Early Retirement?
  • When should I invest – I fear that investing a lump sum in this market may have a negative impact on my returns. How can timing of buying ETFs affect my performance?

Advanced investors may avoid costly mistakes:

  • Challenge my Portfolio – Here is my portfolio – what am I missing? What could derail my strategy?  What can I do to protect my portfolio from shocks?
  • Help me quickly understand – What makes Inflation Linked Bonds outperform? Bond Ladder or Bond ETFs? Why do some investors add Small Cap Value stocks to their portfolios? How can I exclude Tobacco companies from my portfolio? Are the synthetic ETFs I screened safe?  What is Factor Investing?
Currently available in English, French and Polish.
 

Our Introductory Price Levels will end soon. Book your session before new prices apply.

By signing up for a financial coaching session you support our website and our investment research. Here are other ways to help.

Ad
Book a coaching session

Beginners often ask us:

  • How do I reach my goals  What investments do I need to take into consideration when e.g. Taking a Sabbatical, buying a House or saving for Early Retirement?
  • When should I invest – I fear that investing a lump sum in this market may have a negative impact on my returns. How can timing of buying ETFs affect my performance?

Advanced investors may avoid costly mistakes:

  • Challenge my Portfolio – Here is my portfolio – what am I missing? What could derail my strategy?  What can I do to protect my portfolio from shocks?
  • Help me quickly understand – What makes Inflation Linked Bonds outperform? Bond Ladder or Bond ETFs? Why do some investors add Small Cap Value stocks to their portfolios? How can I exclude Tobacco companies from my portfolio? Are the synthetic ETFs I screened safe?  What is Factor Investing?
Currently available in English, French and Polish.
 

Our Introductory Price Levels will end soon. Book your session before new prices apply.

By signing up for a financial coaching session you support our website and our investment research. Here are other ways to help.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Popular ESG Funds can be up to 75% less diversified than non-ESG Funds.
  • They tend to be more exposed to Techs and Telecoms and underweight Energy, Utilities or Industrials. They also have a large cap bias.
  • But the more ESG ratings impact the screening process, the more concentration problems it may pose. Composition may become unintuitive.
  • Conversely, pure SRI Funds are more diversified. Diversification reduction is usually only up 15% compared to traditional ETFs.
  • The sectoral mix of pure SRI funds that don’t rely on ESG ratings is also more intuitive.
  • Pay special attention to the way the ETFs work, rather than their names. While we follow academic conventions related to use of words like ‘ESG’ or ‘SRI’, both iShares and Vanguard have different definitions. 

Here is the full analysis

Comparison of Large ISHARES Blend ETFs

Bankeronwheels.com Sustainable Investing Framework - Spectrum and Focus Of this Section

On paper, the ESG + SRI Blend ETF proposition sounds excellent.

Why not exclude weapons, tobacco or gambling and at the same time also only include the highest-rated ESG companies?

The best part? These funds have outperformed their parent benchmark over the past three years!

Now let’s look at what’s happening behind the curtain.

Comparing the most popular iShares ETFs

We have compared the performance since June 2019 of some of the three largest ESG + SRI Blend ETFs.

These funds all track U.S. companies:

All of them were benchmarked to the ETF using their parent benchmark, the iShares MSCI USA UCITS ETF, which includes all large and mid-cap US Stocks (roughly 85% of  the U.S. total market cap). 

Note that small caps are not consistently rated, so it’s becoming tricky to include them.

What are the SRI Screens applied?

We use the same table we covered in the Sustainable ETFs Benchmark analysis.

However, this one is centred around the benchmarks for our three popular funds.

List of benchmarks with value-based and eSG rating exclusions

As shown in the above table, The MSCI SRI Index includes the most SRI or value-based restrictions. In addition, value-based screening is also heavily applied to the MSCI Leaders Index

On the other hand, the MSCI ESG Enhanced Focus Index includes Nuclear Power. 

To illustrate the above table, let’s look at the exclusions for one of the benchmarks.

MSCI SRI Exclusions

What are the ESG Rating-based exclusions applied?

As shown in the table above, the MSCI SRI Index is the most heavily influenced by ESG Rating selection.

  • MSCI SRI – the Index provider only targets to include up to 25% of the best-rated names from its parent index
  • MSCI Leaders – is also quite restrictive. It includes up to 50% of the best-rated names
  • MSCI ESG Focus – that is used by iShares ESG Enhanced ETF includes 90% of names, excluding the bottom 10% of worst-rated companies

Mind the Fund naming trap

To confuse things, MSCI named its most restrictive ESG+SRI Blend Index the “MSCI USA SRI Index”. Remember, it’s not a pure SRI Index. In fact, it only retains c. 25% of the highest-rated ESG names on top of the SRI screening. 

How do ESG + SRI Screenings impact iShares Sectoral composition?

  • The composition can be significantly impacted by the screening process.
  • Usually, as it’s the case for ESG Leaders and ESG Focus funds, it goes into an intuitive direction: a bit more Tech, less Energy stocks.
  • But the more best-in-class we go (e.g. retaining only 25% of the highest ESG-rated companies) the further the sector composition changes.
  • That’s also because for the SRI fund, MSCI has included a 5% cap per company to avoid excessive concentration risk. 

When the Index Provider has an extremely selective ESG Rating methodology, and on top of that there are additional caps, the result becomes very unintuitive. 

Have a look at the SRI ETF below.

Sectoral Comparison of iShares ETFs

How do ESG + SRI Screenings impact TOP iShares Holdings?

Now, let’s have a look at two tables:

  • The one on the left uses MSCI USA as a reference. It also shows MSCI ESG Ratings for the TOP 25 Names in the Index. And then gradually how much names are dropped once ESG + SRI screenings come into play.
  • The one on the right shows the TOP 25 names in the most restrictive ETF based on the MSCI SRI Index. It then compares the other ETFs to it.

How Much Are ESG iShares ETFs retaining of TOP 25 Names in the parent Index?

The individual names vary a lot:

  • iShares MSCI SRI – Excludes names such as Apple, Amazon, Google or Meta. Not what you’d expect, right? The highest concentration is in names like Home Depot or Nvidia. But I hope you like the taste of Coca-Cola and Pepsi, if you select this fund.
  • iShares MSCI Leaders – Excludes Apple, Amazon or Meta but includes Google. Very high concentration to Microsoft or Tesla. It does that to maintain close replication of sectoral composition with the parent index but at the expense of being over-exposed to these companies.
  • iShares MSCI ESG Enhanced (ESG Focus Index)– Includes all of them but excludes Exxon Mobil or Chevron, which is probably the most intuitive outcome. 

Diversification Is Impacted. a Lot.

Out of the total 623 names in the MSCI USA, the iShares based on MSCI ESG Focus Index holds 571 names (diversification reduction of c.8%), MSCI Leaders 277 (diversification reduction of c. 52%) and MSCI SRI only 151 (diversification reduction of 76%).

DEEP DIVE INTO A POPULAR VANGUARD SRI ETF

Bankeronwheels.com Sustainable Investing Framework - Spectrum and Focus Of this Section

Again, we use the same table we covered in the Sustainable ETFs Benchmark analysis.

However, this one is centred around the benchmarks for SRI-only Funds.

List of benchmarks with value-based and eSG rating exclusions

Deep Dive into Vanguard ESG Global All Cap UCITS ETF

Now, let’s have a quick look at a fund tracking one of the 3 SRI benchmarks above – the Vanguard ESG Global All Cap UCITS ETF.

It tracks the FTSE Global Choice Index

Mind the Fund naming trap

Again, given that there are no naming conventions and probably because the word ‘ESG’ is trendy, Vanguard named its SRI-only Fund “ESG Global All Cap”. Despite what its name may imply, it is not an ESG Fund. Based on the documentation, there is no ESG rating selection. It’s a pure SRI Fund. 

What are the SRI Screens applied?

List of SRI Exclusions

Vanguard applies the same rigorous screening as the MSCI SRI Fund we have previously reviewed.

What are the ESG Rating-based exclusions applied?

Vanguard doesn’t apply any ESG-rating exclusions.

How do SRI Screenings impact Vanguard ETF Sectoral composition?

Sectoral Comparison

Now, let’s have a look at the sectoral comparison:

  • The most significant effect of SRI screening is, as expected, on Energy and Utilities with hardly any remaining exposure in the ESG Fund
  • Materials and Industrials are also marginally impacted
  • The other sectors benefit from relative overweight

How do SRI Screenings impact TOP Vanguard ETF Holdings?

ESG FTSE Global All Cap Top 25 Holdings and Exclusions

Diversification Impact

Out of the total benchmark of 9,523 names in the FTSE Global All Cap, the ESG version is modelled on 8,057 (or a diversification reduction of 15%).

FROM OUR TEAM
Help Us Create Great Resources

This website was created to provide you with all necessary resources to invest without incurring any additional costs.

Servers, data, and software are some of our costs, just to name a few.  Most importantly, our time is the main resource to create great content. If you find that our guides helped you on the path to financial success, you may give us a hand by buying a coffee.

By buying us a coffee you support our website and our investment research. Here are other ways to help.

FROM OUR TEAM
Help Us Create Highest Quality Resources

This website was created to provide you with all necessary resources to invest without incurring any additional costs.

Servers, data, and software are some of our costs, just to name a few.  Most importantly, our time is the main resource to create great content. If you find that our guides helped you on the path to financial success, you may give us a hand by buying a coffee.

By buying us a coffee you support our website and our investment research. Here are other ways to help.

PERFORMANCE - IS THERE MORE TO IT THAN SECTORS?

To summarize – the benchmarks where ESG Ratings are the most intrusive come up with the least intuitive compositions, also because of additional caps.

For example, iShares MSCI USA SRI ETF excludes a lot of names that investors favour, including big tech. 

There is some good diversification of soft drinks – between Pepsi and Coke, but that’s not the type of diversification you probably had in mind.

Pure SRI funds have more intuitive outcomes –  like the Vanguard FTSE ESG Global All Cap ETF.

But what about the performance of ESG and SRI Investments? 

Let’s have a look at this in the next article.

TALK ABOUT THIS ARTICLE

You can comment on articles, tools and discuss wider investing and personal finance topics using our newly set up community forum.

HELP US

Running this website is hard work. If you enjoyed it and want us to help others, you can contribute by setting up a coaching session or buying us a coffee. You can also use our Broker affiliate links when opening an account, at no cost to you. Here are all ways, financially and non-financially, to contribute to our growth.

DON'T MISS ANY INVESTING GUIDES AND TOOLS
SHARE THIS ARTICLE
DISCLAIMER

All information found here, including any ideas, opinions, views, predictions expressed or implied herein, are for informational, entertainment or educational purposes only and do not constitute financial advice. Consider the appropriateness of the information having regard to your objectives, financial situation and needs, and seek professional advice where appropriate. Read our full terms and conditions.