The Millionaire Next Door (Book Review)

THE MILLIONAIRE NEXT DOOR (BOOK REVIEW)

The Millionaire Next Door: The Surprising Secrets of America’s Wealthy by Thomas J. Stanley and William D. Danko is undoubtedly a classic in the personal finance space.

In it, the authors detail what they have learned after interviewing countless millionaires and their families. They dig deep to find out about their habits, economic behaviour, and even their private life.

Published in 1996, the book is still held up as a must-read for many aspiring investors and early retirees.

 

But are the concepts helpful in today’s world, 25 years later? And can European investors apply the lessons learned from American millionaires?   

William D. Danko talks about his book (Helsinki School of Business)

The second part of the above interview is even more interesting.

SNAPSHOT

So, Who Is the Millionaire Next Door?

In 1990s America, the person most likely to be a millionaire was a man, 50+, married to the same woman for most of his life, with 2-4 children. 

Often, the wife didn’t work outside of the home or, if she did, her income was significantly lower.

The millionaire worked for himself, either as a self-employed professional or as a business owner. 

His job wasn’t spectacular or out-of-the-ordinary. 

In fact, he may have been a contractor, an auctioneer, or the owner of a pest control firm.

He almost certainly owned his primary residence. In all likelihood, he was a college graduate, and his income was significantly above average. 

Despite this, he budgeted and lived below his means.

Are you surprised by this description?

I certainly didn’t believe that so many of the millionaires would be business owners, although, after spending three years immersed in the FIRE community, I guessed that frugality played a part. 

The Situation Today

It’s interesting to note that the portrait of the typical millionaire hasn’t changed that much in the past quarter of a century.

Certainly, there are more and more wealthy households led by women, equal partners both earning high wages, or same-sex couples.

But it’s still true that most millionaires are self-employed.

A Dutch study led by Statistics Netherlands (CBS) found that 80% of the country’s households in the 1 million euro or above category were led by a self-employed worker.

Even today, most people who become wealthy still work for themselves.

In my opinion, the eight chapters can be split into three main concepts. 

To find your target net worth, you multiply your age by your income and divide the resulting number by ten. If you are below this, you are an under-accumulator of wealth.

WHAT YOU WILL LEARN

Aspect 1: Frugality and Living Below Your Means

The first and maybe most central theme is that the majority of wealthy people don’t act like they have a lot of money. 

Instead, they work hard, live below their means, and get rich slowly through steady investing.

Only a fraction of the millionaires interviewed inherited their wealth. 

Instead, each generation creates their own fortune by living an average life on an above-average income and investing the surplus.

 

Who are UAWs and PAWs?

A basic concept is the idea of wealth accumulation as a formula.

To find your target net worth, you multiply your age by your income and divide the resulting number by ten.

If you are below this, you are an under-accumulator of wealth (UAW). If your net worth matches the number, you’re an average accumulator of wealth (AAW). And if you have twice the amount of money, you’re a prodigious accumulator of wealth (PAW).

Although it’s fun to play around with, keep in mind that this formula is linear, so it only really works for middle-aged people.

A 25-year-old in their second working year earning £50,000 would have to have £125,000, which is more than they have even earned before-tax at that point.

On the other hand, a 65-year-old in their 40th working year earning the same amount would be expected to have only £325,000. That is nowhere near enough to retire and keep a similar standard of living. For this reason, the formula shouldn’t be taken as a serious measure of success. 

Aspect 2: Efficient Planning of the Offense and Defence

The second aspect explains how wealthy people plan their finances and careers

PAWs spend many more hours a month looking after their budget and investments than UAWs, with the result that they spend less on consumer goods and own more assets.

Because they start building wealth at a young age, they have fewer problems to worry about in their lives.

Government policies are less likely to affect them because a lot of their income isn’t realised. Instead, it is derived from investment growth or property appreciation.

On the other hand, UAWs spend their time thinking about luxury purchases and how to best spend their earned income.

To make this lesson more accessible, the authors have come up with a sports metaphor. 

They state that you need both a good offense and a good defence to become wealthy.

Your offence is the income you earn, so you should maximize the money coming in by getting a lucrative job or building up a successful business. Your defence is how much of your income remains yours.

This is where many people fail: they earn a lot, but it gets spent, so they never accumulate significant wealth.

Aspect 3: Productive Transfer of Wealth

The third lesson was the most interesting to me because it went beyond the usual advice doled out by financial personalities.

It addresses the crucial question of what to do with your wealth once you’ve accumulated it.

As such, this is most relevant to people on the path to financial independence, who are probably already following the advice above.

Stanley and Danko call financial gifts to adult children “Economic Outpatient Care”, and they are mainly against this.

They state that many parents give much more to weak children who don’t display maturity and an ability to earn on their own.

In this way, they “strengthen the strong” by letting them grow independent and “weaken the weak” by encouraging them to accept help.

Instead of following this pattern, the authors tell wealthy parents to spend lavishly on education only and to model frugality in other aspects of life.

Most children will thrive if you let them become independent, emphasize their achievements, and demonstrate that money isn’t the most important thing. 

Parents are encouraged to only give their children money when they have already proved that they can earn and budget on their own.

IS THE BOOK STILL RELEVANT TODAY?

A few outdated social realities

The Millionaire Next Door is outdated in a number of ways, especially when it comes to the gender stereotypes it describes. 

Although income inequality is still a topic, the gap has started to close in the last 25 years, so the typical millionaire can now be either a man or a woman.

The book also fails to address the different family forms that are now common. 

Instead, it focuses on heterosexual married couples with children. In a newer version, this surely would be treated differently.

Are you an Under-Accumulator of Wealth?

Arguably, the target audience is under-accumulators of wealth who need to learn how to spend less, save more, and stop worrying about status symbols. 

Certainly, these people can benefit massively from reading The Millionaire Next Door.

But to me, the book goes beyond that and addresses important topics for people who are already wealthy or on the path to wealth. 

I often hear members of the personal finance community speaking about generational wealth, but this isn’t as easy as many believe.

Personally, I have grown up with PAW grandparents, and I have seen first-hand how some of my family members have not inherited their frugal values. 

The advice about raising children and distributing wealth might have made a big difference  to the way my own family handled their wealth transfer. 

Looking beyond Self-Employment

As a self-employed teacher and writer, I was pleasantly surprised at the fact that most millionaires also work for themselves. 

I understand why: you have a much closer relationship with your finances if you directly control what comes in and what goes out.

I never have the security of knowing that a pay check will come my way at the end of the month. Instead, I only get paid when I work.

On the flipside, I can pick up more work to get paid more. 

This direct relationship between my time and my finances has encouraged me to take control and even join the FIRE movement.

Despite this, most people are probably not suited to self-employment.

Many businesses fail, so it is a risky path

The book states that the millionaires interviewed are the outliers, so their success isn’t the average outcome of working for yourself.

For this reason, most people looking to become financially independent are well served by staying in a high-paying job and accumulating their wealth through aggressive saving and investing. 

Once you’ve started focusing on your finances, your employment status has a lower contribution to the level of your financial success.

SHOULD YOU BUY THIS BOOK?

Beginner-Friendly
5/5
Financial Freedom
5/5
Investing Concepts
2/5
Personal Finance Know-how
3/5
Investing How-to (Europe)
1/5
OVERALL RATING
3.5/5
Beginner-Friendly
5/5
Financial Independence Principles
5/5
Investing Concepts
2/5
Personal Finance Know-how
3/5
Investing How-to for Europeans
1/5
OVERALL RATING
3.5/5

Rating justification

The Millionaire Next Door: The Surprising Secrets of America’s Wealthy by Thomas J. Stanley and William D. Danko is a highly informative and entertainingly written book about how to become wealthy, how to stay that way, and how to transfer your wealth to the next generation.

The book is beginner-friendly and explains how truly wealthy people lead a frugal existence and find satisfaction in their work and family life.

It assumes that the reader knows nothing about America’s millionaires and therefore explains everything clearly.

Although the examples are based in the US, the characteristics of wealthy people are the same in European countries.

Explaining exact investing strategies is outside of the scope of this work, and it focuses more on the mindset than the how-to.

Additional reading would be required to dig more into how to set up a simple portfolio and what you need to know about investing.

That said, I would highly recommend this classic to investors in the EU and the UK who are looking to get rich slowly and steadily over time.

REFERENCES

BROWSE ALL RESOURCES

GROW YOUR PORTFOLIO
PROTECT YOUR MONEY
CHOOSE THE BEST ETFs
INVESTOR CHECKLIST
Market Dashboard
RECOMMENDED RESOURCES
BOOK REVIEWS
INVESTING FAQ
UNDERSTAND BOND ETFs

DISCLAIMER

All information found here, including any ideas, opinions, views, predictions expressed or implied herein, are for informational, entertainment or educational purposes only and do not constitute financial advice. Consider the appropriateness of the information having regard to your objectives, financial situation and needs, and seek professional advice where appropriate. Read our full terms and conditions.

REACH FINANCIAL INDEPENDENCE SOONER

Invalid email address
Exclusive features will be available to members only. And as you've seen, High Quality Research you won't get anywhere else. Unsubscribe at any time.
About Kathrin 7 Articles
Kathrin is an independent teacher and writer with a keen interest in Personal Finance topics. As a self-employed, she quickly realised that she had to take her financial future into her own hands, so she has studied how to save, invest, and plan for Early Retirement. Kathrin joined BankeronWheels.com to bring a new perspective as she started her portfolio from scratch in her early twenties and understands the challenges people face when first starting out. Kathrin currently lives in London but grew up on the continent and also takes a view of a European reader. Kathrin gets around on her foldable and electric GoCycle GX bike.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
8 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Steveark
1 month ago

Good book review of a good book. While many of my friends made money like me running large corporations I have a few friends who did own pest control companies or had an auction business or a tree service. All of them know how to handle money and live within their means.

KathrinS
KathrinS
1 month ago
Reply to  Steveark

Hi Steveark, thanks for stopping by. It’s interesting that within the FI community, most people are more traditionally employed, which would suggest that the self-employed are no longer the wealthiest group. But studies like the one mentioned confirm that they are still more prevalent among the affluent than would be expected. I can certainly see how being responsible for your work would make you more keen to save and invest.

Werner
Werner
1 month ago

Even if some social realities might be outdated, it’s main message is still very true: smart people are frugal and build wealth, not so smart people keep up appearances.
This books remains a classic and should be a mandatory read in every high school.

Kathrin Spinnler
1 month ago
Reply to  Werner

Hi Werner, thanks for stopping by. I totally agree that this book should be read by every young person, as it can really change your outlook.

James
James
1 month ago

One thing my parents have told me every day is to never get a credit card. They are in their 40’s and are still paying off credit card debt from their 20’s

Kathrin Spinnler
1 month ago
Reply to  James

Wow, that sound scary, James. Not building up any credit card debt is definitely great advice, and this topic is also covered in the book.

Tim
Tim
1 month ago

Another book to be added to my reading list. Thank you for this useful review.

Kathrin Spinnler
1 month ago
Reply to  Tim

Hi Tim, I’m glad you enjoyed my review. Let me know what you thought of the book once you’ve read it.